The African Athena Controversy Essay -- Ancient History

With the nonattendance of assurance, serious credibility is a reasonable way to deal with attempting to decide the impacts that the Egyptians and Phoenicians had on the Ancient Greeks. Since the distribution of the Bernal’s Black Athena volumes I and II, an extraordinary discussion has surfaced. There is no doubt that the Egyptians and Phoenicians had an effect on the Greek culture, the inquiries that are being questioned is the specific idea of the relationship and what timeframe this relationship existed. Subsequent to perusing the three articles introduced, I have come to concur with Martin Bernal and his Revised Ancient Model of Greek causes. At one time Egypt was acknowledged as European, yet that status started to dissolve and in the 1790’s Egypt was viewed as an African Nation. Preceding the 1820’s the most generally acknowledged hypothesis of the birthplaces of Greece was the Ancient Model. In this model, crude clans, Pelasigians, and others possessed Greece. In specific locales of Greece, the Egyptians and Phoenicians settled, constructed urban areas, and cultivated the locals. The Phoenicians were credited with having presented the letters in order while the Egyptians showed the Pelasgians water system (Bernal, p. 7). It was during this period, the Northern European researchers started to give occasion to feel qualms about the colonization of old Greece by the Egyptian and Phoenicians and their social advancement of that time (Bernal, p. 7). â€Å"Historiographical advancements can't be connected to the accessibility of any evidence† (Bernal, p. 7). Unfortunately, there were some incredible revelations found after the models changed, yet they were overlooked, similar to Jean-Francois Champollion discoveries, he had started to interpret the hieroglyphics during 1820’s, the decipherment of cuneiform, and the primary circular segment... ...ilization and driven me to concur with Bernal’s Revised Ancient Model. References Berlinerblau, J. (1999). The Aryan Models. Blasphemy in the University: The Black Athena debate and the reponsibilities of American scholarly people [Portfolio perusing set]. Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston: http://www.UMB.edu Bernal, M. (2001). Presentation Black Athena composes back [Portfolio perusing set]. Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston: http://www.UMB.edu Lefkowitz, M. R. (1996). Old history, Modern Myths. Dark Athena Revisited [Portfolio perusing set]. Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston: http://www.UMB.edu The African Athena Controversy [Portfolio perusing set]. (2012, June). Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston, CEHD, CLA, CPCS, CSM, and CNHS Writing capability assessment (WPE): http://www.UMB.edu The African Athena Controversy Essay - Ancient History With the nonappearance of conviction, serious credibility is a practical way to deal with attempting to decide the impacts that the Egyptians and Phoenicians had on the Ancient Greeks. Since the distribution of the Bernal’s Black Athena volumes I and II, an incredible discussion has surfaced. There is no doubt that the Egyptians and Phoenicians had an impact on the Greek culture, the inquiries that are being questioned is the specific idea of the relationship and what timeframe this relationship existed. In the wake of perusing the three articles introduced, I have come to concur with Martin Bernal and his Revised Ancient Model of Greek sources. At one time Egypt was acknowledged as European, however that status started to dissolve and in the 1790’s Egypt was viewed as an African Nation. Preceding the 1820’s the most generally acknowledged hypothesis of the causes of Greece was the Ancient Model. In this model, crude clans, Pelasigians, and others possessed Greece. In specific locales of Greece, the Egyptians and Phoenicians settled, manufactured urban areas, and humanized the locals. The Phoenicians were credited with having presented the letters in order while the Egyptians showed the Pelasgians water system (Bernal, p. 7). It was during this period, the Northern European researchers started to give occasion to feel qualms about the colonization of antiquated Greece by the Egyptian and Phoenicians and their social improvement of that time (Bernal, p. 7). â€Å"Historiographical improvements can't be connected to the accessibility of any evidence† (Bernal, p. 7). Tragically, there were some incredible revelations found after the models changed, however they were disregarded, similar to Jean-Francois Champollion discoveries, he had started to translate the hieroglyphics during 1820’s, the decipherment of cuneiform, and the primary circular segment... ...ilization and driven me to concur with Bernal’s Revised Ancient Model. References Berlinerblau, J. (1999). The Aryan Models. Apostasy in the University: The Black Athena debate and the reponsibilities of American erudite people [Portfolio perusing set]. Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston: http://www.UMB.edu Bernal, M. (2001). Presentation Black Athena composes back [Portfolio perusing set]. Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston: http://www.UMB.edu Lefkowitz, M. R. (1996). Antiquated history, Modern Myths. Dark Athena Revisited [Portfolio perusing set]. Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston: http://www.UMB.edu The African Athena Controversy [Portfolio perusing set]. (2012, June). Recovered from University of Massachusetts at Boston, CEHD, CLA, CPCS, CSM, and CNHS Writing capability assessment (WPE): http://www.UMB.edu